Baked Chicken Quesadillas made in the oven so you can make multiple quesadillas at the same time! Stuffed with Mexican seasoned chicken and capsicum/bell peppers, plenty of gooey cheese and enclosed with crispy golden brown tortilla, this is how you can make quesadillas for a crowd without standing over the stove, making them one by one. 🙂
Last month I went on a mini break with friends and we hired a gorgeous swanky house right on the beach at Sapphire Beach (Coffs Harbour) on the New South Wales North Coast. And my darling friends, they insisted that I mustn’t do much cooking, that I must relax.
Well! Isn’t it lucky that I did get a bit organised with a shopping list and meal plan. Because in the entire 4 nights / 5 days we were there, we only went out for ONE MEAL. In fact, other than that brief 2 hour outing, we only left the house for a short 20 minute stroll on the beach before we declared that the pool and our sun lounges were beckoning us back (along with the frozen mango daiquiris we had planned to start making the minute the clock ticked over to 12 o’clock).
.
There were only 4 of us, and yet making Quesadillas for lunch was still a pain. As I stood over the stove cooking them one by one, popping them in the oven and praying they would stay crispy until I finished, I vowed to find a way to make a big batch in one go.
So I figured how to make crispy Chicken Quesadillas in the oven. 🙂
It wasn’t as easy as just wacking stuffed folded tortillas in the oven. I found a few little tricks made quite a difference:
-
Letting the filling cool. As a general rule for anything, it’s takes longer to get a crispy surface in the oven than in a fry pan. So if you use hot filling, the extra steam inside the quesadilla makes the tortilla too soggy to go crispy (unless you way overcook it to the point of very brown);
-
Spray the tray with oil and pop it in the oven to heat up. Yup, that really helps make the underside get crispy once it is flipped; and
-
Crank up the oven – but not too much, otherwise the edges get too brown before the surface gets crispy all over.
I stuffed these Baked Chicken Quesadillas with the makings of Chicken Fajitas! Seasoned chicken, onion and capsicum / bell peppers. Plus cheese of course. Mustn’t forget the cheese!
There’s no denying that they don’t come out quite as shatteringly crispy as you can make them on the stove by pressing down firmly on the quesadillas while they cook. But these are still crispy – crispy enough!
Also the other thing I observed is that the tortilla starts to wrinkle after around 20 minutes. Here they are after I had been faffing around with the camera for around 30 minutes – you can see how different they look to when they are fresh out of the oven (photo above).
Small compromises for the sheer convenience of of being able to make a big batch in one go!
I hope you find this Oven Baked Chicken Quesadillas recipe handy! I’ve always felt like quesadillas are like pancakes – only make them in select circumstances, when there aren’t too any people to feed.
But now you can make quesadillas for a crowd – even with two trays so you can make 8 at the same time – or more if you have a large oven! – Nagi x
PS You can see how crispy they are in the video (below recipe) when I am stacking the quesadillas. 🙂
More things stuffed between crispy flatbreads!
Things stuffed inside crispy flatbreads are always a good thing! I’ve done a few over the years:
-
Gozleme – Crispy Turkish olive oil flatbreads stuffed with spinach and feta
-
And though not stuffed, this ever popular Easy Soft Flatbreads has to make the list (use as naan for curries, Greek Gyros, Doner Kebab, Chicken Shawarma – the options are extensive!)
Hungry for more? Subscribe to my newsletter and follow along on Facebook, Pinterest and Instagram for all of the latest updates.
Oven Baked Chicken Quesadillas
Ingredients
Chicken
- 400 g / 14 oz chicken , cut into small bite size pieces (thigh, breast or tenderloin)
- 1 tsp cumin powder
- 1 tsp garlic powder (or sub with onion powder)
- 1/2 tsp cayenne pepper (or adjust to taste)
- 1 tsp paprika powder
- 1/2 tsp salt + black pepper
- 1 tbsp olive oil
Filling
- 1 tbsp olive oil
- 1/2 small onion , diced (brown, white, yellow)
- 1 garlic clove , minced
- 1 red capsicum / bell pepper , diced
- 1 green capsicum / bell pepper , diced
Quesadillas
- 4 flour tortillas (20cm/8")
- Olive oil spray
- 1 cups grated cheese, or more to taste (tasty, cheddar, Monterey Jack, Pepper Jack or other melting cheese of choice) (Note 1)
Instructions
- Place Chicken ingredients in a bowl and mix to coat chicken.
- Heat oil in skillet over high heat. Add onion and garlic, cook for 1 minute. Then add capsicum and cook for 2 minutes until starting to soften. Transfer into bowl.
- Return skillet to the stove. Add chicken and cook until browned. Add to same bowl. Set aside until the filling cools (to speed it up, cover and refrigerate, and/or spread out on plate).
- Preheat oven to 220C / 430F (standard) or 200C/390F (fan / convection).
- Spray baking tray lightly with olive oil. Heat in the oven while you assemble the quesadillas.
- Divide the filling between the tortillas, covering half the surface. Top with cheese. Fold in half and press down gently but firmly.
- Remove baking tray from oven. Transfer quesadillas onto tray (you should hear a soft sizzle).
- Bake for 8 minutes. Then turn the quesadillas (over the folded edge) then press down with the egg flip. Bake for a further 8 minutes or until the surface is crispy.
- Remove from oven and serve immediately!
Recipe Notes:
a) Cooling the filling first (reduces steam inside the quesadilla while baking);
b) Heating oiled baking tray; and
c) Cooking in a fairly hot oven. 3. You can make 2 trays of this at the same time. It will take around 5 minutes longer and the trays should be swapped partway through. The tray that ends up at the bottom will probably need a few minutes longer after you take the top one out. 4. Oven Baked Chicken Quesadillas nutrition per serving (1 quesadilla).
Nutrition Information:
WATCH HOW TO MAKE IT
Oven Baked Chicken Quesadillas recipe video!
LIFE OF DOZER
Usually when I go away, I send Dozer to a Golden Retriever boarder’s place where he rules the house with other Goldies. However on this occasion, he was injured (#DefectDog) so I sent him to my mother’s place where he would be free of temptations to rumble with other Goldies.
My mother (and actually, my whole family) get sick pleasure in torturing me when I go away and they don’t send me Dozer updates unless I plead multiple times. Finally, she sent me ONE photo – this one.
Humph. His usual boarder is so much better. I get daily reports and tons of photos – without any begging!!!
What’s your recipe for the Frozen Mango Daiquiris? Seems like something is missing without them ha ha
Hi! How long should these be in oven if I’m using corn tortillas instead of flour?
I guess this was posted a long time ago, but i wanted to comment anyway. I made these quesadillas for dinner tonight and my entire family LOVED them! I haven’t had this many compliments on dinner in forever. Everyone wanted seconds and thirds and…
Love these. So easy and tasty.
Great method! Tasty quesadillas. I’ll never wreck a pan by making them one by one again! Thanks for sharing.
I’m always looking for something I can add to the meal rotation and many recipes end up getting the ax by my kids
This was a winner! Also, they were enjoyably crispy without shattering into bits, like tacos can-perfect
So delicious, definitely going to make again in the near future.I served with avocado sauce… yummy!
Made these last night & they were so good. I can’t believe how easy they were to make. I made the feeling earlier in the day popped it in the fridge & then it only took a few minutes to assemble. So tasty my husband & I loved them & I also made the avocado dip which went perfectly with it. Thank you Nagi again for a simple easy to follow recipe but it looks so impressive.
Really delicious! I used leftovers from the weekend BBQ instead of cooking more chicken. It was a huge hit with the family. Will be making this again… 🙂 Thank you for a great recipe!
My husband loved these!!! They were so delicious! Thank you Nagi for helping out a newlywed! <3
Winner winner chicken dinner
Hi Nagi,
Love your recipes 🙂 do you have any tips on how to make the tortillas stick so that the filling doesn’t fall out please ? 🙂
Hi Carissa, the cheese is the glue here that holds everything together! N x
I’ve made a few of your recipes lately and love them – prime rib roast being the latest – Yummo!
As far as cooking quesadillas in bulk, I’ve done them in the oven folded in between 2 sheet pans. No need for a weight. Works well!
Took me a while to great round to baking this one, shame I didn’t try it earlier. It was delicious. I have tried similar recipes before, your were better. Suspect it was the choice of spices that made the difference!
This recipe is really good – much better than I expected. The tortillas are crispy, but not dry, and the spices on the chicken are perfect. I served it with salsa, guac, and sour cream. My husband said it was “restaurant quality”. I can’t wait to check out other recipes on your website! Thanks for the delicious and easy to prepare meal that was enjoyed by my whole family!
Hi, Nagi! I love, love your recipes AND your sweet puppy, Dozer! I made these quesadillas and they were fantastic! (as all of your recipes are!) I did add a chopped Poblano pepper to the mix for added spice. I love your idea of making them in the oven bc you can make more–esp good when you have guests. I am in the Midwest and it is very hot here (90s & HI is in the triple digits! ugh!) Take care and have a great weekend!
The Quesadillas was the first Nagi recipe I tried. It was a supersuccess. After having it a number of times we now make bigger batches of the filling. This has made it really quick to make. Good served with Salsa, Guacamole and some fries. It also good to put a baking tray covered in the oven while you make them in the pan. This allows you to make 8 or 10 and put them in the covered baking tray as you make them. Cover them over with foil while you devour them 2 at a time (1 each).
Perfect Darren!!! N x
I just made these and they were the best ever! I will never fry quesadillas again. The oven was so easy, faster and they came out more crisp! I used leftover chicken (already cold), spinach and cheese and put them in the oven as directed. They came out a little too overdone in my oven at 430 degrees. So, the next batch I only cooked 5-6 minutes per side and they were still crisp! SO easy! And delicious. Thank you!!
Wahoo, you nailed it Emily! N x
Loved it, you had 3 rules and I had been breaking them all. Thank you so much. Everyone wants to fry of coarse but I’m a working mom so….. p.s. liver the name Dozer, I’m old so fragal rock ruled for me in 1st grade. That’s the name I gave my first dog ever. Rock on dozer!
I won’t tell anyone Amanda 🤫 😂
After setting fire to my frying pan (long story) the day I needed to make quesadillas, I was on the prowl for a good oven baked version. I came across this website via a Google search and it really saved me. Thanks Nagi! I’ll be checking out your other recipes too!
I couldn’t help but laugh Brian – I’m glad the quesadillas were a hit and hopefully you don’t set fire to anything else in the near future! – N x